return to home page



Erika Schwartz, M.D.  
 



Power Surge™ Live!
Host: Dearest
Guest: Erika Schwartz, M.D.
Menopause And Natural Therapies



Read more about Erika Schwartz, M.D.
About Erika Schwartz, M.D.

The Hormone Solution
Read "The Hormone Solution"

Dearest: It would take an hour to give you tonight's guest's credentials, so briefly, Erika Schwartz, M.D. is a healthcare pioneer, a woman's physician, a researcher and expert on all things hormonal. Dr. Schwartz is the author of two books, "Natural Energy," and "The Hormone Solution." She has appeared on TV shows like The View and has been quoted in Newsweek, Vogue, The Wall Street Journal, USA Today and Self Magazine, fielding queries about hormones and stress, hormones and aging, hormones and the life cycle. Montefiore Medical Center sponsored and aired a four-year television program produced and hosted by Dr. Schwartz, Health Horizons, the first program in the greater metropolitan NY area directed at bridging the information gap between physicians and patients. Dr. Schwartz has a true passion and commitment to empower and educate women to be the healthiest they can be. She's been practicing medicine for 20 years and specializes in women's health. Dr. Erika, it's great having you back in Power Surge. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: I am blushing. Dearest: Nah Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You are too kind. Dearest: Don't blush. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: OK, I'll just answer all questions. Dearest: I'd like to start off with a little free association, if you're game. I'll give you a word or phrase (i.e., name of a medication, medical condition, et al), and you tell me the first thing that comes to mind. Also, if you'd care to elaborate on it, please feel free to do so. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Good Dearest: Ok. Dr. Erika, you can give me a one word answer, or a description, whatever comes to your mind. #1: PremPro Erika Schwartz, M.D.: A bad synthetic drug that spent too much time in our systems and consciousness and has stopped us from getting informed on issues of hormones. Dearest: #2: synthetic hormones Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Substances foreign to our bodies, impostors that replace our hormones and often times wreak havoc in our systems. Dearest: #3: Bio-identical hormones Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Hormones that are molecularly identical to our own hormones, that gently supplement or boost the missing or out of balance hormones in our bodies. They look and act exactly like our own hormones but are made from yams and soy oils and are processed and concentrated by pharmaceutical processes to allow our bodies to use them as their own hormones. Dearest: #4: Premenopause, perimenopause, postmenopause Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Labels given by conventional medicine to times in our lives when our hormone balances aren't working well and thus need to carry a diagnosis to get treated. Dearest: Labels for what? Elaborate, please. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: I personally believe these labels should be eliminated and we should focus on how we feel regardless of age or label/diagnosis. Dearest: Thanks, Dr. Erika :) Erika Schwartz, M.D.: My pleasure. TMM: I am having hard time adjusting the dosage of estrogen and progesterone. (I increased the estrogen too much and I got too revved up and raised my blood pressure last month so I was more cautious this month but) I tend to get a lot of panic attacks along with other symptoms (dizziness, shortness of breath, weakness, palpations) ESPECIALLY the last week before my period. Is a panic attack an indication of too much progesterone or too or too little estrogen? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: A panic attack is the result of an imbalance between many hormones. Estrogen and progesterone are only two in a rather complex dance. Your balance of estrogen and progesterone is very important and I hope you have a good physician helping you figure out how best to accomplish the dosing. Estrogen alone may increase the anxiety yet progesterone alone may not be the balancer you need. Get some good help. Dearest: TMM, what kind of estrogen and progesterone are you taking? TMM: E3-3mg E2-1.5mg Progesterone 200mg (in duragels) per day, all natural. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You are taking a lot of both estrogen and progesterone. I would reconsider the balance. TMM: OK, I will talk to my doctor. Thank you very much. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: My pleasure, hope you feel better fast. TMM: I wasn't aware they were high (These are topical). Jan9: I had a hysterectomy 3 years ago and was on 5mg. estradoil and now the doctor has me tapering off them. I am now on .5mg and I get hot flashes day and night. I also use progesterone cream should I start taking Revival? What course of action should I take? Sorry this is my first time! Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Jan9, you need both estradiol and micronized progesterone. You need to have them balanced. Taking soy protein alone will not help. Jan9: Why not natural progesterone? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Taking a combination of soy, estradiol (in lower doses) and progesterone will accomplish the goal. Dearest: Okay, Dr. Erika, you mentioned estradiol and micronized progesterone. Why, when you prescribe natural hormones, don't you include estriol? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Estriol is a weak estrogen most abundant during pregnancy. All the studies on Estriol have failed to demonstrate significant benefit over estradiol. Estradiol is the estrogen most abundant in young women in their 20s and early 30s when women are the healthiest so I work with the ideal estrogen and by staying with only one estrogen, the studies I undertake are more meaningful over the long term. Cabo: What is micronized progesterone? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Micronized progesterone is the most commonly used form of natural progesterone - it is in minute particles - hence the name micronized and it supposedly gets absorbed the best into the human system. Dearest: Are there any real benefits from using over the counter natural progesterone creams? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Depending on the symptoms you are trying to treat? If you are young and just have PMS or bloating before your period and mood swings, OTC progesterone has its place. As we age, OTC progesterone becomes less efficacious because we need higher doses and combinations with estrogen to obtain the right balance. Dearest: As our estrogen levels decrease, you mean, yes? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Actually, progesterone levels decrease before. Dearest: In short, it's less effective as our estrogen levels decrease. Ok. thanks. LMichelin3: I am on Vivelle dot .01 and Prometrium 100 mg. due to POF (premature ovarian failure) and all the symptoms of menopause. I had constant bleeding for 60 days. D&C (dilatation and curettage) found polyps. My bleeding continued. I bleed every 6 days. I have Hepatitis C. I am 41 and need help please. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You need to have the hormones cycled. If you take both all the time, you may never stop bleeding. LMichelin3: Cycled? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: So ask your doctor to cycle your hormone regimen. Cycled means following the natural monthly cycle, like three weeks on and one week off. Isie: I just had surgery to remove large fibroid tumor and polyps. Could that have caused the anxiety I have been having? The tumor did not show on needle sonogram. He didn't find it until surgery which was February 5th. I was taking Estrus and prometrium but have stopped since surgery. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: The fibroids are hormone related tumors. Anxiety is caused by hormone imbalance. You are right. They are connected. Jimi: Welcome Dr. Could you please explain the importance of DHEA and Melatonin and the effects of long term stress, menopause and the aging process. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: DHEA is a hormone precursor meaning from it many hormones are made. Melatonin is a neurotransmitter hormone meaning it is a brain hormone. As we age, all hormone levels drop and stress accelerates the decline, or wear and tear, on our hormones and bodies and minds. Menopause is a time that is arbitrarily designated as the time we stop menstruating. Actually our hormones don't just disappear the day we stop having our periods. They decrease over time. Diet, exercise, lifestyle, stress management, sleep. Everything contributes to either staying young and healthy well into our old age or getting sick and infirm. Dearest: Thank you, Dr. Erika. What an excellent answer! Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You're welcome. Moozie: I'm 44, 3 years post, severe anxiety, chest pains, not on hormones yet, are my symptoms normal? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Your symptoms sound like they are ruining your life, how could that be normal? Moozie: Yes, they are. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You need help. Find a doctor to work with you and make sure you don't have an underlying medical problem and then start you on natural hormones and a plan to balance your life and allow you to enjoy it. Dearest: Erika, what if a doctor won't work with a woman on natural hormones? Will you work with them? Moozie: Are these symptoms of menopause ? Dearest: Moozie, email me at Dearest@aol.com for the symptoms. That would take another hour alone. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Of course I will. I also help interested physicians learn how to use natural hormones. Dearest: Moozie, if you're suffering from severe anxiety, of course they can be symptoms of your anxiety and menopause. Moozie: What about chest pains? Dearest: Moozie, you need to be checked by a doctor to rule out any other health issues, but you can have chest tightness and pain from severe anxiety. However, I wouldn't immediately attribute chest pain to that until you're given a clean bill of health, right, Erika? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You are right Dearest and I would strongly recommend everyone gets checked out when they have symptoms to make sure there are no medical problems overlooked. Dearest: Right. I always recommend that in Power Surge - not to assume everything is from menopause. Other health issues can develop during menopause, too. Thanks. Carrie: What do you think of the herbal supplement named New Phase? Is it possible to have an allergic reaction to herbal supplements such as this?I am certain I did. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Herbals are not any different than drugs or medications. They can cause allergic reactions. If you don't feel well when you take any type of medication stop taking it. Carrie: I had an enlarged uterus, bleeding. Dearest: Erika, did you want to comment on Carrie's last remark about having an enlarged uterus and bleeding? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Carrie, when you bleed a lot, it is a result of too much lining in the uterus and hormone imbalance. Have an ultrasound to rule out any problem and then do get natural hormones to minimize the problem. Carrie: I had 4. After a month the uterus had returned to normal. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You had 4 what? Carrie: Thank you, I found a good Doctor who gave me some. I had 4 ultrasounds done. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Good Diamond: I am planning to take the MCAT in April 2005 and hopefully be accepted in Med school, Class of 2009. I am 51 now and a senior at UTC, is this an impossible dream? I know I would be a good MD, Family Practice and Women Issues and how they relate to nutrition. Thanks, Dr.Erika! Erika Schwartz, M.D.: I believe as long as you can breathe you should do everything you want especially when you can help. I wish you the best of luck and I am sure you will be an asset to the medical profession. Diamond: Very encouraging, Thanks so much! Dearest: Very ambitious of you, Diamond. Lots of luck! Erika Schwartz, M.D.: With love to you. Debrikkia: Do the same remedies that apply to those who are going through natural menopause, apply to those of us who have gone through surgical menopause many years ago? Can the same remedies work? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Deb, natural hormones work at all ages and times. If you need help balancing your hormones it doesn't matter if your problems are surgically induced or induced by Mother Nature. CathyJ: Dr Erika, could u please tell me if menopause can affect your eyes not to focus right? Through the day they act up like when u first open your eyes in the morning, but it happens to me all day on and off. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Deteriorating eyesight is par for the course in the aging process. Menopause or not, our eyesight fades. DBYKAY: Dr. Erica, I was showing and feeling all the changes in life but the blood work showed nothing. How can this happen? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Blood work shows nothing. There is no blood test on the market that correlates our symptoms to real hormone levels so you have to rely on how you feel when you make decisions to treat your symptoms. No one but you lives in your body so you have to learn to read your body's messages to stay healthy. GGc0ok: Is there a bio-identical natural estrogen cream for internal use? If so, what is it? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: GG what do you mean by internal? GGc0ok: To use for atrophic vaginitis, I'm all dried up. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You need to balance your hormones internally into your system not your vagina. When your hormones are in balance in your blood stream, they will restore your vagina to a moisturized environment. In addition, you can also use topical testosterone and combinations of estradiol and micronized progesterone around your vagina, but you need to attack on all fronts if you want to get rid of the dried up feeling. Dearest: Erika, is the testosterone available in the Natural Hormone Pharmacy? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Yes, it is. Dearest: Wonderful. Patty: I am on Estraderm patch since total abdominal hysterectomy in 2000. Is it safe to stay on patch forever? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Not estraderm. It is a synthetic estrogen like the one in Premarin and Prempro. You also need progesterone even if you have no uterus. Patty: Why? I was told it was a plant estrogen. I was told no uterus, no need for progesterone. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: It is a derivative of estradiol, not quite the same thing. It doesn't come from horse's urine but is isn't natural either. The problem is that while you have no uterus, you still have breasts, brains, heart, muscles and bones, and they all NEED progesterone!! Patty: Is it safer? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Estraderm? Not much. If you have other options, why not use them? Patty: What would you recommend? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Estradiol and micronized progesterone in transdermal cream form in a dose to be determined by your weight and symptoms. Dearest: She recommended natural hormones, naturally compounded not mass manufactured by a large pharmaceutical company. Dancern22: I am 51 and in menopause. I use Revival daily and also Remifemin daily. My PAP smear showed inflammation. Is this due to menopause (vaginal PH)? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Dancern, not sure. It could be from the combination of hormones you are taking or from some type of mechanical irritant. I am sure your doctor is going to repeat the PAP smear after treating you with an antibiotic for a couple of weeks. I would also evaluate your hormone regimen at that time. DoloFrnk: I'm on natural HRT, (55) postmeno. Can you tell me, should I totally rule out the standard blood testing for hormonal levels in military health care system, which is the only way they test? I'm on e2 .125, e3 .5 and p 100mg (oral). Is this likely to counter breast tenderness? I can't tell if a progesterone level of 8.53 as being high is too high and maybe causing the tenderness for about a week where I didn't have any before? No bleeding. I switched from natural progesterone cream to the micronized, oral capsule combined with the 80% estriol, and 20% estradiol, trying to find the right balance is the trick when only blood tests are what the military doctors go by. My blood level for estrogen was about 126. Should I just go by symptoms or the lack of? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: The blood tests aren't going to be of any help, so you are right, go by symptoms. But if your breasts are tender, do not ignore the symptom. DoloFrnk: I can't seem to get military to pay for saliva testing. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: I believe you might want to reevaluate the amount and type of estrogen you are getting. Saliva testing doesn't work any better than blood. Jan9: Should I get off estradoil since my doctor recommended it? It's not a cream and do I need a prescription for the transdermal creams? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: All natural hormones in dosages that really work are available by prescription only. Estrogen cannot be obtained in over the counter preparations at all. I don't know why your doctor recommended you go off estradiol. Jan9: I think it was all the hype about hormone replacement therapy. LMichelin3: My Physician said that I would stop bleeding when I get used to the hormones. Does cycling involve blood hormone levels? Any Chicago referrals. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You will stop bleeding when your system decides to stop bleeding. Cycling does not involve blood tests. It involves understanding what your body is experiencing and knowing how to react to keep yourself in balance and feeling good. SuperGrammieJean: After having a baby in my 20's I developed severe panic attacks and anxiety. Could this have been caused by a hormone imbalance? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Of course. Most post partum blues is the result of rapid decline in hormone levels and too little progesterone left behind. A little progesterone goes a long way to prevent the need for antidepressants in a healthy woman who gets sad after she has a new baby. Dearest: Erika, when you think about it, isn't it ridiculous that they'll put women on Effexor, Prozac, Paxil, Neurontin, all sorts of anti-seizure medications and anti- depressants and anti-anxiety pills when all they might need is some form of natural hormone supplement? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You said it!!!!! Dearest: Why on earth are women being prescribed anti-seizure medication for menopause. I do not know. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: I spend my life taking young women off those poisons!!! We take them, that's the problem. We don't say NO! Dearest: Some of us don't. Many are empowered to say no now! Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Thank God. I hope more as we do our work. Jimi: Could you explain exactly what is happening we we have a hot flush or flash as you call them in the US and are these damaging to our system if occurring regularly? And is there any connection between them and anxiety or panic and the adrenals? I have had a lot of trauma over a long period of time and now feel depleted. I wish we had access to this info twenty years ago. I am 50. Using natural compounded progesterone and DHEA cream for 3 weeks. Dearest: There's an excellent article in the Educate Your Body section of the Power Surge Web site called What's a hot flash. It describes the whole process you're going through. You can read it at www.power-surge.com/educate.htm Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Hot flashes are basically caused by sudden changes in hormone levels starting from our master gland in the brain- the pituitary. Over time, they do wear us out and it is the way Mother Nature intended to get rid of us as we age. However, we are a new breed of women and Mother Nature's plan is not OK with us. So we found natural hormones, diet, exercise, stress management, SLEEP, and many supplements and vitamins to help us. DHEA doesn't always work, you should be able to tell if it works within two weeks of starting it. If you feel better, stay with it, if not, get naturals and the rest of the plan. Cindor: What is your opinion about Flaxseed oil to alleviate night sweats and hot flashes? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Flaxseed oil is a good fatty acid source, it will help your body make hormones if it can. If your body can no longer make the hormones you will need supplementation from the outside. CathyJ: Dr I have one more question. My doctor tried me on all types of estrogen, and nothing worked for me. I take depakote and dilantin for seizures could that be why none of the estrogens worked for me? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Depakote and dilantin are very harsh drugs. But if you need them, you have to work around them. You need to address all areas of your life to support and minimize the negative effects of the drugs. I also do not believe you cannot take estrogen with progesterone. Maybe your doctor hasn't tried everything yet. I don't believe in giving up - EVER! Isla: I'm not taking any medications, am 37 and have been experiencing 'perimenopausal' changes for the last three years. Symptoms are mostly mild and manageable, (apart from intense heel pain). Are there any long-term health issues I need to be more aware of, or taking action on? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Yes. Learn your family history and make sure you are taking great care of yourself NOW, not in 10 years. Debrikkia: You said that whether we have a uterus or not, we still need progesterone. I have been taking a bio-identical natural hormone replacement for nearly 3 years. The doctor I am seeing now, is wondering why I am taking any progesterone whatsoever since I have had a hysterectomy. Why would there be a question there? Sorry, by now, you may have already answered this question, but I'd still like to hear it again. Erika Schwartz, M.D.: You need progesterone because you have receptors for it on every cell in your body. The cells need progesterone to function well. If you have no uterus, you still have a heart, a brain, bones and muscles and they all need progesterone, not to mention your breasts. Isla: I worry about bone density at my tender age. Can you reassure or is that the family history? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Bone density is a disease of the makers of Fosamax. If you have a family history and are totally sedentary. Yes, no worries. Worry will make you old and sick. MariaJ: I'm 3 years since last period and feeling pretty good. Took tri-est for 1 1/2 years and weaned off. Still take progesterone cream. Do I need to take a break? Some say 5 days month or few weeks every once in awhile? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Take a break every few months for about a week. Trish: I am 49 and postmenopausal, started meno at 38. I have no, not low, sex drive, what should I be taking? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: Estradiol, progesterone and testosterone and make sure you are in a relationship with someone who really turns you on. Salaskie: My naturopath has said that getting my adrenal glands functioning properly will get the anxiety attacks under control and help balance my hormones. What do you think? Erika Schwartz, M.D.: The naturopath is probably right. Dearest: Erika, thank you for a very informative chat about natural methods of treating menopause and natural hormone therapy. I also recommend Dr. Erika Schwartz's books, The Hormone Solution and her earlier book, Natural Energy. Read Dr. Erika Schwartz's first transcript Read Dr. Erika Schwartz's third transcript Read Dr. Erika Schwartz's fourth transcript Read Dr. Erika Schwartz's fifth transcript Disclaimer: Every guest in Power Surge is a highly respected professional whose opinions are his/her own. An appearance in Power Surge does not constitute an endorsement of a guest's views. None of these transcripts may be reprinted or reproduced without the express permission of Power Surge™ and the respective guest. Read other transcripts by returning to the Library. Dearest aka Alice Stamm Power Surge Founder, Facilitator, Host Copyright©1994-2008 by Power Surge. All Rights Reserved.


Return To Library / Read more this guest / Home